Daily Health Reviews

Arizona immigration law hearing ends with no decision

PHOENIX – A federal judge in Phoenix did not rule on whether to block a new Arizona immigration law on Thursday after two hours of testimony at the hearing first and foremost one of the seven challenges for strict enforcement.

The Phoenix police officer who filed the suit could be dismissed if it does not enforce the law has filed a lawsuit to block, a lawyer said U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton, who did not say when he had to decide whether end the law before its entry into force on 29 July.

Lawyers for Governor Jan Brewer, said U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton demand – by Officer David Salgado and nonprofit groups statewide Chicanos Por La Causa – should be rejected as Salgado and lack of standing group and that no valid claim of immediate harm.

But Salgado’s lawyer did not agree.

“He has a real threat,” said attorney Stephen Montoya. “They can fire him. That’s enough.”

Bolton is considering blocking the law and whether to dismiss the lawsuit. She can not act before the law is established with effect from 29 July.

Hearings on the six demands, including one by the federal government, are set for next week.

Protesters and supporters gathered outside the law courthouse, separated by at least seven Phoenix police officers carrying guns and handcuffs.

About two dozen supporters, many dressed in red, white and blue, held signs praising Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, a major endorsement of the crackdown on illegal immigrants, and one that says “American Pride” .

Larry Templeton, 66, of Sun City, said he came to support the bill because he believes in the rights of states.

“They are saying it is racist. It’s not against any race, is anti-criminal,” said Templeton, who wore an American flag T-shirt and a hat with American flag buttons.

About 10 feet away, about 30 people who opposed the law held banners calling for their repeal.

“We demand an injunction. We demand federal intervention,” shouted opponent Sandra Castro of Phoenix, 22, into a megaphone.

The law requires police, while the application of other laws, the question of the status of a person if immigration officers have a reasonable suspicion that the person is illegally in the country.

Supporters say the law was necessary because the federal government has not adequately confronted illegal immigration in Arizona, the busiest illegal entry of immigrants into the United States. Opponents say the law would lead to the establishment of racial profiling and distract the attention of the police official “traditional in the fight against crime in their communities.

Montoya said the U.S. Separate Department of Justice challenge to the Arizona law strengthens the argument of their customers that state law is unconstitutional. Both lawsuits argue that state law intrudes on the federal government’s constitutional authority to set and enforce immigration policy and regulation.

“That’s one more opinion,” said John Bouma, a private attorney representing Brewer. “The fact that filed the complaint did not mean they are right.”

The courtroom large ceremonial in federal court in Phoenix principal was filled with more than 100 spectators, the audience began. More than a dozen lawyers had established over two L-shaped tables, divided equally on each side. The jury box was filled with law clerks for judges working in the building that came to observe.

From Brewer signed into law April 23, was inspired by the meetings in Arizona and elsewhere by proponents of both sides of the immigration debate. Some opponents have called for a boycott of tourism in Arizona.

It also led to an undetermined number of illegal immigrants to leave Arizona for other American states or their countries of origin and asked the Obama administration to file a lawsuit to invalidate the law.

Salgado lawyers argued that the judge should block the law before its entry into force, as it would require an officer to use race as a primary factor in the application of the law and because state law is defeated by the federal immigration law.

Brewer’s attorneys asked that the formal demand will be thrown out because Salgado alleges no real threat of harm to enforce the new law and instead bases its claim on speculation. He also said state law prohibits racial discrimination and is not overcome by federal immigration law because it does not purport to regulate the conditions under which people can enter and leave the country.

The other challenges to the law were submitted by the U.S. Department of Justice, civil rights organizations, religious groups, a researcher at Washington and a police officer in Tucson.

Bolton is scheduled to hold similar hearings on July 22 lawsuits filed by the federal government and civil rights groups.

Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reservados.Este material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

“”

Most Active Discussions

States have the authority to enforce immigration laws and protect its borders, Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox said Wednesday in a legal brief on behalf of the nine states supporting the law of Arizona is immigration.

A federal judge in Phoenix did not rule on Whether …

Arizona immigration law hearing ends without Rulin …

Immigration: a divided nation, Phoenix, Arizona, …

Source article Read more at MSNBC



Arizona judge has the first hearing immigration law

Protesters demonstrated outside the law of Arizona the Angel Stadium during the All-Star game.

An Arizona judge Thursay held the first hearing on the seven challenges are brought to tough new immigration law of the state, which will enter into force on 29 July.

Thursday’s hearing before U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton is not in the federal government’s challenge to the law, which requires police officers to verify the immigration status of a person stopped for another offense if the officer believes there is a “reasonable possibility that people who have left the country illegally.

The law has generated intense debate in Orange County and throughout the country. The City of Rancho Santa Margarita on Wednesday night passed a resolution supporting the right of Arizona. He joined several other Orange County cities that have expressed such support, including Costa Mesa, Yorba Linda and Orange.

The first challenge was filed by Phoenix police officer David Salgado and nonprofit groups around the state called Chicano Porla Cause. His suit uses the same argument that the federal-immigration is a federal responsibility. His action also says the law should not enter into force because the officers would be obliged to use race to determine who it is, something the Arizona Governor Jan Brewer says is not true.

Click here to read the full story of the AP.

But on immigration:

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

What we are seeing before our eyes is the transformation of a country of law and order to the country a banana republic. Anyone can walk across the border, have a couple of kids, and take the train for a bargain. When the hard working taxpayers realize they are being taken for a ride at the last stop is the financial ruin?

AMEN !!!!!

Blame immigrants for everything now.

Illegal! DS, illegal …. Immigrants are legal entry into our country, do it right.

Legality has nothing to do with immigration. His parents knew that well.

Main Entry: IM · grant ˝ miles
Pronunciation: \ i-mə-grənt \
Function: noun
Date: 1789

: One that migrates: as a: a person who comes to a country to establish permanent residence b: a plant or animal to be established in an area where it was previously unknown.

BS –

That was a bad attempt to combine the themes … by definition there is no such thing as a person who enters into any country and break the law … there are no laws …

It may be that his accomplice a liberal or some kind of an anarchist

“Begotten” What? How to create debate. In fact, the only debate is who is the Nazi of the week.

“Necessary” in any place required by law career to be used. David Salgado official asinine asinine.

agreed.

Interesting. Judge Bolton was recommended by Arizona Republican Senator John Kyle and was nominated by President Clinton to the bench.

It is likely that supporters will be illegal to purchase in the prisons to find a judge who has a history of being an apologist for the border crashers to put the law on hold. Naturally, they are called a ‘victory’, while in reality it is not. Finally, the law will be enforced. All the arguments against legal sense with virtually zero little precedent to support their arguments. What we are seeing now is pure theater.

You wonder why your Federal government has never sued a sanctuary city MANY to be in flagrant violation of federal immigration law. Their justice system and courts are supposed to be “blind”, no? hah.Siempre lady looks at the statue outside the court with holding the scales of justice? Look closely at a teardrop under his eye as well. I think one is being formed.

AMEN!

very simple explanation: Immigration is not a crime but a civil offense punishable by deportation. Its application is exclusive Federal Authotiites.
States therefore can not make their own laws “criminalize” immigration is the real question so if there was an immigration reform that language can be there and then and only then can the local application to do this work.
I suppose this is very difficult to understand after years of using the word “criminals” and “illegal” instead of “undocumented.”
Here is Mr. Rudy Giuliani explain things well:

Whatever the case, illegal and should not be here to begin.

In any other country if they were illegally imprisoned it would probably be tortured and then deported. Here we provide healthcare, education, and financial assistance to minimize the hard working taxpayers of our country.

My hat off to people in Arizona who made this bill, and those who counsel men and women in Orange County who support them. Playing an active role in government should not be popular, it must do what is right. All the opposition of this bill originates in a predominately Hispanic origin and legislators just bites his tongue during the election season to secure the Latino vote.

While some might argue that racial profiling is to ask for documentation of residence, no one has considered the fact that if you are a U.S. resident who has been held (eg by a traffic violation) for as simple as showing your driver’s license to confirm their status as U.S. citizen. Driving without a valid U.S. license drivers, or any other documentation of identity would be an ideal reason to detain someone until their identity can be determined. If you can not find in the system address and social security number, then yes, it is a reasonable assumption that the detainee is not a U.S. citizen and immigration services should be contacted.

This is not really a fair process for people.

Gee ya think SALGADO Office has an agenda?

This law does not require police to use race to determine who it is. If, indeed, forbids it.

Yes, I would suspect Salgado officer to be in the making.

Come on, you’re blind? Do you think the cops are going to go up to white people and ask to see their papers? Race is an important part in determining who it is.

Whenever I’m stopped by a white police officer asking me for my words, papers. Driver’s license ID card. What is your point of Brown?

How often was detained because of their immigration status is in question?

No one shall be arrested in Arizona simply because of their immigration status is concerned. Read the law before making false statements.

BrownAndDumb
Do you think the police are just trolling looking for Latinos to track to check their immigration status? what a fool.
Oh by the way have been in Mexico City or Guadalajara Jalisco lately? If there was a track, there are quite a few white Mexicans down there too. I guess because you do not have BrownAndProud … LOL

Brown and proud …. you only get question after committing a crime and if you suspect are illegal.

SOLUTION: do not commit any crime

THE END

wow that was easy

I hope that the good officers in Phoenix PD reject this jerk.

I just saw a Fox News video of some cameras set up on federal land by the Center for Immigration Studies posted within 15 miles of the border, and Casa Grande Sector (80 miles inside the border). The video shows hundreds of foreigners including armed drug dealers walking calmly through the border without any sign of police or border guards. The cameras can record infrared and columns of illegals was the day and night.

What kind of government we have to authorize these flagrant violations take place and choose to spend our tax dollars rather than punish a state for trying to enforce the law?

sparky wrote:

“What kind of government we have to authorize these flagrant violations take place and choose to spend our tax dollars rather than punish a state for trying to enforce the law?”

************************************************** *************************

One who has completely lost touch with the ideals and policies of our founding fathers, and has sold its own citizens (blood) by river. “Representative democracy” has no more practical sense in the U.S.. Now we have the rulers “to promote selective forms of anarchy. Impressive.

Sad to say ocobserver’re right.

very true … beautifully said

Seeing that the CIS is an organization founded by a white racist supreme, edited out all the patrols Border Patrol agents.

Oh, I see and I suppose that the aliens were just actors paid by the bag of dirt from the CIS to be seen as illegal and edited with the patrol on the ground in bringing all these people. LOL you are the man or woman a lot.

Oh by the way in response to another of his stupid comments no, I quit because I look like an illegal alien, but if the officer did better than having a reason to stop me or be willing to make an arrest or am I not he showed no what they call “papers”

Desert Sun … you need to stay out of the sun …. The same old white supremists bad eh? Of course, the Brown Berets style scouts are just kids … reconquest

Desert Sun, now if we are to draw what they perceive as racist organizations, why no mention of La Raza, MECHA, Brown Berets, and the rest of the Mexica Movement BS organizations?

As for the signs that the protest group is using, my question is … group can sue the MLB MoveTheGame.org for copyright infringement to use the MLB logo without permission? (Assuming you did not give permission.) “Here’s the American way … a lawsuit.”

Here’s the video:

Kevin the video looks something like referred to on Fox News this morning, but the news reported that they were much more recent.

Oh. Sorry. I have this video from the Center for Immigration Studies, the date the video was in July 2010. If you have another video, or news agency that issued would be interested in seeing it!

Thanks

If you were right. When I saw the utube video thought the date was 2001. My mistake. The year was 2010.

Very revealing video eh?

Revealing and terrifying! Thanks for sharing, I’m definitely going to be passing along I know.

Here is some food for thought however. Many Latino advocates the DREAM Act of 2010. Here is some information I bet you do not know yet. There are two requirements to become a legal citizen, I will display the text directly from the account.

“(D) The alien has completed at least one of the following:

(I) The alien has acquired a degree from an institution of higher education in the United States or has completed at least two years, in good condition in a program for a bachelor’s or higher degree in the United States.

(Ii) the alien has worked in the uniformed services for at least two years and, if discharged, has received an honorable discharge. ”

Think you could only get student loans for education? Think again:

“Notwithstanding any other provision of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 USC 1001 et seq.) Or any provision of Title IV of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 (8 USC 1601 et seq.) With respect to federal financial assistance to education, an alien who is lawfully admitted for permanent residence under this Act and has not removed the conditional nature-not eligible

(1) federal Pell Grants in Part A of Title IV of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 USC 1070th et seq.), Y

(2) Federal Supplemental Educational opportunities in Part A of Title IV of the Act (20 USC 1070b et seq.). ”

So basically the federal government is trying to refill cannon fodder for the war in the Middle East. I hope that the felling If you speak Spanish

Thanks for the video. Very revealing and a must for anyone with the AZ SB1070, especially the Obama administration.

Kevin – Your take on the “Dream Act” is interesting.

Oh, do not misunderstand me. I do not support the bill, but if politicians bend under the weight of the Latino vote, I sure would be interested in seeing the results.

~ If you thought furnish proof of residence is a reason to start boycotts and riots, and wait till they find out they have to put their children in the first line of a war!

Kevin, I’m not trying to be argumentative I appreciate your point of view, but I doubt that many of these people will join the military to become citizens.

The way we read things like this (the “Dream Act”) is that on the surface of the ratings appear to kill some people and it seems difficult to achieve, but the caveat is that the government has demonstrated that it enforces on the books, if so would not have the problem. . So what is happening is simply a paper mill in a candidate for the “Dream Act” submit a form and fills it with an oath to tell the truth and not going to see that funciona.El candidate only a list of or whatever school they attended and send it and that it will be. And of course, by the way the new “citizen” be allowed to sponsor their parents and other relatives.

The government has no resources to locate or verify the information and do not want in any case.

The government is doing the smoke and mirrors thing to try to convince the gullible electorate who have your best interests at heart when nothing could be further from the truth.

Do not think about it from this perspective. If you cannot even secure the borders, how can they do meet the requirement for recruitment and education?

Good point.

Kevin thanks for the debate. All I can say is keep your eyes open to the smoke and mirror attempts … is tricky business.

Have a great day.

Dena Bunis always has a story like this with photos of the protesters holding signs professionally printed’m always curious as to the origin of such signs. The one is in the hands of the angry young man in the photo that was given some free stuff to take the sign, sponsored by the usual socialist and communist organizations usually sponsor these things. Here’s a link to a page that lists the “members” who come together to defeat Arizona

Depth Reporting guess it’s not the forte of Dena.
Otherwise none of the reporters also OCR.

ll Hey Sparky … I bet the SEIU gave them to idiots

LOL If you do not want all the signs that are not produced by a union that flew around.

Dear Felipe Calderon

His criminals are returning home. They have been our problem long enough. So we are returning the problem that left us. As you can see more and more cities and states across the country are getting on board with sending the illegals back home. Polls show a majority that says: “We want the illegals to return home.” We are pulling the plug on the gravy train.
As president must do their best country. But like the rest, you also fail.

Sincerely,
USA

They all meet again here and discuss why lost.Bolton 1070 is very likely that the granting of an injunction and other federal courts, as they always do, to maintain the supremacy clause.

You are not aware that AZ has been questioned 14 times by federal immigration on the past and is 14-0 AZ. The feds surely LOOSE this case as they have done in all other … Only hope is that some police beats in a unique case and can not contest in the future on that basis.Now add to this the fact that nine states are already on record blasting obamao to prosecute …. Not to mention he played the race card, but none of his cases are based on race …. And the fact that many other states passed the same legislation in the near future …. and you lost BIG TIME obamao on many levels!

Mensy’m sorry … but the historical record simply do not share

What you fail to mention is that the Az. E-Verify law was challenged last week and will go through the courts as well.

That has nothing to do with the price of tea in China …. What have been the fault of those challenges??

Bottome line is that the feds have been beaten over and over again when they face … is not the most likely indicator of what will happen again to look into the past?

His logic is faulty …. You are betting on the lions when they should bet on the Saints …. That’s what the facts say, but you have a gut feeling that your right and you like the color of their helmets??

I’ve seen better argue that bro ….

If SB 1070 lives or dies, has done its job. It has energized people on both sides of the debate. Obama and the Liberal Democrats have much to gain by keeping the border open and promote amnesty. They also have much to lose as most Americans do not want any amnesty until the border has been secured.

SDLAD – Americans as a whole, do not worry about this issue.It affects about 13 states, at most.
Why do not you think that it was a hot topic last election? Just do not register with most Americans radar.Additionally the interests of big business will never allow politicians to kill the goose that continues to lay golden eggs. Wake up and smell the coffee, is all about money and power for all them.When to vote, you get a choice of Tweedledum and Tweedledee, bought and paid for by all bycorporate interests.

What happened to obamao be focused like a laser JOBS … remember that the state of the Union promise?? He has not said a word about the work … where in the hell do not come from immigration?? Why break your promise? Are you trying to convinve that amnesty in any way to give Americans their jobs?? Or maybe a play a more sinister?? Obamao Does not even care about Americans at all??

The worst of the economy more people will pay attention to those who are here with the resources that should go to Americans who are instead going to foreigners.

Thinking about 20 million illegal aliens from qualifying for the care of Obama after the amnesty should be sufficient in itself to people awake. The doctors are refusing Medicare patients Obama care. What will you do next medical force to these people as patients?

When the hammer and the cycle of raising more capital?

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

Source article Read more in Orange County Register